Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8

Jump to Recipe

If you’ve ever eaten at Jersey Mikes, then you know Jersey Mikes club sub is the best around. Now you can make them at home!

If you’ve ever eaten at Jersey Mike’s, then you know their club subs are the best around. (And if you haven’t…you don’t know what you are missing!)

But what if you don’t live near a Jersey Mike’s? (We do not have one near us in NY.)

Not a fan of subs? As much as I enjoy the Jersey Mikes Club Sub, I love home-cooked meals and am looking forward to a corned beef dinner this week.

Or what if you just want to enjoy one of these delicious subs at home?

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (1)

Well, I have good news for you – I’m going to share with you my copycat recipe for Jersey Mike’s Club Subs.

The delicious, yet messy sandwiches made with turkey, ham, bacon, and cheese, Mike’s way!

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (2)

Now you can make them at home – and they’re just as good as the originals! (if not better, because you can use more of what you like!)

This recipe is perfect for a party or large group, and it’s sure to please everyone.

So get out your cutting board and start slicing – these subs are about to become your new go-to meal! (I know they’re mine!)

Serves 2

Prep time – 10 minutes

Jersey Mike’s Copycat Recipe Ingredients

Hoagie rolls (I use Martin’s because that’s what is available here in Florida)
Mayonnaise
2 ounces thin-sliced Ham (I use Boars Head)
2 ounces thin-sliced Turkey breast (again, I use Boars Head)
Thinly sliced tomatoes
Sliced onion
Shredded lettuce
4 slices of bacon (or more!)
Submarine oil
Provolone cheese
Salt
Pepper
Oregano

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (3)

Mike’s Way Ingredients

Mike’s way is when they add onions, tomatoes, lettuce, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, oregano, and salt.

Copycat Recipe Tips

I know by now that you are probably wondering why my subs look funny.

I’ve tried making each individual sandwich its own way. However, the ingredients never stay in place and more ends up on the plate than on the sandwich. And then the roll hinge breaks and it drives me crazy, lol.

By laying down the first roll and layering the ingredients on the club sub that way, it’s so much easier.

But you can do it whatever way is easiest for you. It’s still going to taste like a Jersey Mike’s Club Sub no matter which way it’s made.

What Kind of Meat Does Jersey Mike’s Use

Jersey Mike’s uses meat that is raised without antibiotics. It is distributed through Clemons Food Group and the pigs are raised on American family farms where they are fed a vegetarian diet.

Can I Make my Own Jersey Mike’s Olive Oil Blend

The olive oil blend is called “the juice” at Jersey Mike’s. And by all means, if you have the ingredients, go right ahead and make some.

It’s a blend of 2 parts vinegar and 3 parts good virgin olive oil. I like to keep things easy which is why I use bottled submarine oil.

How to Make a Copycat Recipe Club Sub from Jersey Mike’s

Start by slicing open your hoagie rolls if they are not already sliced.

Spread mayo on each side.

Layer your ham and turkey.

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (4)

Then add your bacon, cheese, and tomato.

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (5)

And onion and top with shredded lettuce.

Squirt your submarine oil on top of the lettuce.

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (6)

Then sprinkle salt and oregano.

Cut your submarines in half both ways and enjoy.

Copycat Recipe Jersey Mike's Club Sub #8

If you’ve ever eaten at Jersey Mikes, then you know their club subs are the best around. Now you can make them at home – and they’re just as good as the originals!

Prep Time10 minutes

Total Time10 minutes

Ingredients

Hoagie rolls (I use Martin's because that's what is available here in Florida)
Mayonnaise
2 ounces thin-sliced Ham (I use Boars Head)
2 ounces thin-sliced Turkey breast (again, I use Boars Head)
Thinly sliced tomatoes
Sliced onion
Shredded lettuce
4 slices of bacon (or more!)
Submarine oil
Provolone cheese
Salt
Pepper
Oregano

Instructions

Start by slicing open your hoagie rolls if they are not already sliced.
Spread mayo on each side.
Layer your ham, turkey, bacon, cheese, tomato, and onion.
Top with shredded lettuce.
Squirt your submarine oil on top of the lettuce.
Then sprinkle salt and oregano. Add the other roll.
Cut your submarines in half and enjoy. Yes, it’s messy, but it’s sooo good.

Notes

Mike’s Way Ingredients

Mike’s way is when they add onions, tomatoes, lettuce, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, oregano, and salt.

I use the submarine oil already mixed in a bottle that’s available at grocery stores and it tastes the same.

Club Sub Tips

I know by now that you are probably wondering why my subs look funny.

By laying down the first roll and layering the ingredients on the club sub that way, it’s so much easier.

But you can do it whatever way is easiest for you. It’s still going to taste like a Jersey Mikes Club Sub no matter which way it’s made.

What Kind of Meat Does Jersey Mikes Use

Jersey Mikes uses meat that is raised without antibiotics. It is distributed through Clemons Food Group and the pigs are raised on American family farms where they are fed a vegetarian diet.

Can I Make my Own Jersey Mikes Olive Oil Blend

The olive oil blend is called “the juice” at Jersey Mikes. And by all means, if you have the ingredients, go right ahead and make some.

It’s a blend of 2 parts vinegar and 3 parts good virgin olive oil. I like to keep things easy which is why I use bottled submarine oil.

Nutrition Information

Yield

Serving Size

1
Amount Per ServingCalories 615Total Fat 37gSaturated Fat 10gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 24gCholesterol 96mgSodium 2104mgCarbohydrates 37gFiber 4gSugar 8gProtein 34g

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

So now you can enjoy one of these subs any time you want!

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (18)

Jersey Mike’s Club Sub recipe is a delicious combination of flavors.

One of the key components of this iconic sandwich is the Jersey Mike’s Juice recipe, a carefully crafted blend of red wine vinegar and olive oil that infuses every bite with a zesty and tangy kick.

The secret lies in the perfect balance of Jersey Mike’s Oil and Vinegar recipe, which lends the sub its signature dressing.

This harmonious blend complements the layers of freshly sliced turkey, ham, and crispy bacon, making the Club Sub a true delight for the taste buds.

It’s a culinary masterpiece with every bite, thanks to the distinct Jersey Mike’s Olive Oil blend that brings out the best in the sub’s ingredients.

Copycat Jersey Mikes Club Sub #8 | Easy Everyday Recipes (2024)

FAQs

What kind of oil and vinegar does Jersey Mike's subs use? ›

Red wine vinegar and an olive oil blend. It's how a Jersey Mike's sub gets its exquisite zing. It's how bites get boosted, and a great sub becomes an even better one. The Juice adds that certain something extra.

What brand of deli meat does Jersey Mike's use? ›

And to ensure the best taste and quality, Jersey Mike's serves the Certified Angus Beef ^® brand. A guy named Mike opened the first Jersey Mike's location in 1956 in Point Pleasant, N.J It was later purchased by — get this! — a 17-year-old high school kid. Talk about childhood ambition!

See Details ›

What kind of mayonnaise does Jersey Mike's use? ›

chipotle mayo. and then the fastest chopper.

Know More ›

What kind of lettuce does Jersey Mike's use? ›

Served with freshly grilled Applewood smoked bacon, shredded iceberg lettuce and perfectly ripened tomatoes, try it Mike's Way for that extra and unexpected zing you've been missing.

What kind of tuna does Jersey Mike's use? ›

with 2 types of tuna. we use albacore and light tuna. and I get customers say, oh, man, you should put rally. you don't put relish, you don't put onions.

What kind of cheese does Jersey Mike's use on their cheesesteaks? ›

This famous Philly cheesesteak is the real deal. It's grilled fresh to order with tender steak, peppers, onions, and white American cheese. Order this fan favorite today!

Learn More ›

Does Jersey Mike's use boar head meat? ›

They use Boars Head cold cuts, fresh baked rolls, make the sandwich with anything you want on it for the same price but it's twice as big. As far as anything else goes, with the exception of the quality of the meat, there is little difference between Jersey Mikes and Subway except the price.

What kind of oil and vinegar goes on a sub sandwich? ›

Oil, Vinegar and Spice

We suggest you use and Extra Virgin Olive Oil, however you can get crafty with different varieties. Balsamic Vinegar works, however, we suggest a nice red wine vinegar for your homemade Italian sub sandwich.

Find Out More ›

Does Jersey Mike's have vinegar and oil? ›

The authentic sub sandwich, served Mike's Way with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices, is what differentiates Jersey Mike's from the others.

Keep Reading ›

What kind of oil and vinegar do sub shops use? ›

Subway uses red wine vinegar and blended olive oil (canola oil blended with extra virgin olive oil) but you really should try different things, I myself like a little balsamic vinegar and a garlic infused oil. There isn't a special sandwich oil or vinegar. Fat (oil) is tasty and so are acidic foods.

What is Mike's Way oil? ›

mike's Way. onions, lettuce, tomato, red wine vinegar. and we put a good amount of vinegar, olive oil blend. we put a good amount of olive oil, oregano, salt.

Read The Full Story ›